Some data recovery companies deliberately damage a hard drive’s unique modules when they cannot recover the data or when the client refuses to pay, so that nobody else can recover it either. The safeguard is simple: a professional lab should make a full copy of the drive’s service area and photograph its condition, and the client has the right to ask for these copies and photos.

How it happens

A common situation: a client brings in a hard drive for data recovery, does not accept the price the company asks, which is sometimes considerable, and wants the drive back. A company left without payment may deliberately damage unique modules in the drive’s service area or elsewhere, so that other data recovery companies can no longer recover the data.

Examples from our practice

We do not name the companies involved, but such cases do occur.

  1. Destroyed or replaced modules. Quite often we receive drives whose unique modules have been completely destroyed or replaced. Checking the structure of the service area makes it obvious that the company that worked on the drive before us did everything it could to make sure that nobody after it could recover the data.
  2. Physical damage. Sometimes a drive has been damaged physically. Even then it is possible to establish accurately whether the drive failed on its own or was damaged on purpose. Sometimes it is down to a technician’s lack of skill, sometimes it is deliberate: particles are added to the drive, the head holder is bent, and so on.

What a client should ask for

A professional lab with specialised equipment should:

  • make a full copy of the service area, with modules and tracks – not just for a report to the client, but above all for data safety;
  • take photos of all outer surfaces of the drive and, if it was previously opened at home or by another company, of the inside as well;
  • photograph the drive whenever it is opened in any lab, and after opening it in a clean room, give the client a dust particle report.

We believe a client has the right to ask for these copies, reports and photos after the initial inspection of the drive.

If your drive came back from another company without data

If your hard drive has already been to another data recovery company and came back without the data, we can examine it fully. If the drive was opened, we photograph the inside with the client present, so that it is clear what condition the drive was returned in.

Drives are sometimes returned without their dust filters, with bent magnetic coils or with various foreign particles inside. None of this happens in normal use; it can only be done deliberately.